What does American made mean to you?


For the last year, I have urging everyone I know to consider buying more products manufactured by members of our extended American family.  I have featured a lot of these products on this blog.  But what does it mean for a product to be made in America or American made?  Well, as you might have guessed, the devil is in the details.  The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is charged with preventing deception and unfairness in the marketplace. The FTC requires that a product must be “all or virtually all” made in the U.S. before it can be advertised as being “Made in USA”.  That seems simple enough.  But is it?

The FTC has provided guidance as to what it means to be “all or virtually all” made in the U.S.  A product that meets this standard is entitled to what the FTC calls an unqualified “Made in the USA” claim.  There are two factors in this standard; the manufacturing factor and the parts factor.  The FTC standard for “All or virtually all” means that final assembly or processing of the product must take place in the U.S. and the product should contain no or only a negligible number of foreign parts.  The FTC provides two examples to help make it crystal clear.

Example: A company produces propane barbecue grills at a plant in Nevada. The product’s major components include the gas valve, burner and aluminum housing, each of which is made in the U.S. The grill’s knobs and tubing are imported from Mexico. An unqualified “Made in USA” claim is not likely to be deceptive because the knobs and tubing make up a negligible portion of the product’s total manufacturing costs and are insignificant parts of the final product.

Example: A table lamp is assembled in the U.S. from American-made brass, an American-made Tiffany-style lampshade, and an imported base. The base accounts for a small percent of the total cost of making the lamp. An unqualified “Made in USA” claim is deceptive for two reasons: The base is not far enough removed in the manufacturing process from the finished product to be of little consequence and it is a significant part of the final product.

I may be a bit thick, but I didn’t get the answer to either of those examples right.  But it gets worse.  The FTC warns manufacturers that before they may use an unqualified “Made in USA” claim they should “look back far enough in the manufacturing process to be reasonably sure that any significant foreign content has been included in their assessment of foreign costs. Foreign content incorporated early in the manufacturing process often will be less significant to consumers than content that is a direct part of the finished product or the parts or components produced by the immediate supplier.”  Returning to the FTC’s grill example, does the answer change if the starter switch has 75% US content, but 25% content from Canada?  What if the tubing used for the burners are made manufactured in the US, but 30% of the iron ore used to make the burners came from Peru?  I don’t know about you, but that kind of analysis makes my brain hurt.  But I guess if you want to make an unqualified “Made in the USA” claim, you should have to prove that you are making a product in the U.S. with U.S. parts.  But sheesh, it sure seems like a lot of work.

Manufacturers who are unable to make an unqualified “Made in USA” claim can often make a qualified “Made in USA” claim.  A qualified “Made in USA” claim describes the extent, amount or type of a product’s domestic content or processing; it indicates that the product isn’t entirely of domestic origin.

Finally, a manufacturer  that can’t meet the standard necessary to get a qualified “Made in USA” claim can opt for an “Assembled in USA” claim.  But there are standards for this claim as well.  According to the FTC, as long as “substantial” assembly occurs in this country, a product may be labeled “Assembled in USA” regardless of the source of its parts.

This American made labeling issue can be contentious.  U.S. shoe manufacturer New Balance has been the subject of a lot of attention on the labeling issue.  New Balance states on its website, “Twenty-five percent of New Balance shoes sold in North America are produced by our US workforce using US and imported materials. When possible, we obtain materials from domestic suppliers. At times, due to availability, economic or quality reasons, there is a need to import components from foreign sources.  Where the domestic value is at least 70%, we have labeled the shoe “Made in the USA.” Where it falls below 70%, we have qualified the label referencing domestic and imported materials. This determination is based in part on the Federal Trade Commission’s survey of consumers.”  New Balance employs 1,200 U.S. manufacturing workers in this country making its shoes.

The labeling issue also came to the fore recently with the opening of the “Made in America” store in Elma, New York.  Mark Andol is the founder of the store and the store has been featured on Fox News, the ABC “Made in America” series, and NPR.  Mr. Andol’s goal is the same goal I have: to create manufacturing jobs for Americans by having you and I buy American made products.  Mr. Andol’s store  appears to sell only products that meet the FTC’s unqualified “Made in USA” claim standard.  I guess I am less of a purist than Mr. Andol.  If the choice that a U.S. consumer is considering is between a “Made in USA” product and an “Assembled in USA” product, I would urge them to buy the former.  But if the choice is between a product manufactured overseas versus an “Assembled in USA” product, I would urge them to buy the latter.  I would like your take on that question.

If you have time, please leave a comment on the issue of whether you agree or disagree with me on my “Assembled in USA” position.  Do you think American consumers should take an all or nothing approach to the made in America issue?  Do you only consider an unqualified “Made in USA” product to be a made in America product?  Please chime in.

Advertisements

About tapirking

I live in Seattle and love telling stories about Americans, the places where they work and the things that they make.
This entry was posted in american made, Made in America, Outsourcing, Website and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to What does American made mean to you?

  1. In dealing with clothes only, it would be best that clothing material be made in USA and all assembled in the USA. Most clothes if they are assembled in the US, the material is also (but not always) made in the US. But since only 2% of clothing is made in USA, sometimes just assembled in the USA is acceptable. Assembled elsewhere, but with American materials is not acceptable. -Jack A.

  2. CB says:

    I build guitars- Almost all guitar manufacturers who use Mahogany, Rosewood, Ebony and exotic woods have to import the wood(s). Even if they buy from a supplier in the US- the wood still comes from another country. The same can be said for many of the shell and abalone pieces that make up the inlays on the instruments fretboard.
    However- these larger guitar manufactures label their instruments Made in USA (I have no problem with that) …. Even though the guitars are cut, assembled and finished in the USA the actual material(s) that make up the whole are imported. You can’t make a guitar without wood or the other components.
    I guess my question/comment is- how negligible/non negligible is the wood ?
    I would like to say my guitars are built in the USA because I follow the basic process- get wood , body blanks, fretboards , neck blanks etc- cut them out, paint, finish and assemble them (I am a one man operation) right here in the US.. however- I don’t have the money to fight if the FTC were to say something… It’s a tough call.

  3. Caleb says:

    I still wish there was more clarity with this issue….for instance, Danner boots advertises on some of their models on the website “made in usa with imported parts”, but the boots will have an american flag on it. Seems a valid advertisement if the entire boot was imported but sewn together domestically. I’m not concerned about origin of glues, hooks, eyelets, etc, but would love some clarity as to where the leather is from, tanned, etc. Feels like they use the vague labeling system to keep you uninformed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s